Environment Court evidence

Northland Regional Council, iwi, hapū, and community groups submitted evidence to the Environment Court to inform its decision about the new marine protection rules for Mimiwhangata and Rakaumangamanga (Cape Brett).

Submissions covered six broad areas: Cultural matters, ecology and natural character, economics, fisheries, planning, and recreation and tourism.

Cultural matters

Ngāti Kuta
Matutaera Clendon, Robert Willoughby and George Riley – Evidence in chief (19 March 2021) (PDF 26.73 MB)
Matutaera Clendon and Robert Willoughby – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 1.89 MB)
George Riley – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 718 KB)
Te Uri o Hikihiki
Carmen Hetaraka – Evidence in chief (19 March 2021) (PDF 1017 KB)
Carmen Hetaraka – Rebuttal (23 June 2021) (PDF 1.98 MB)
Vania Keefe – Evidence in chief (19 March 2021) (PDF 1.85 MB)
Ngāti Manuhiri
Terrence (Mook) Hohneck – Rebuttal (23 June 2021) (PDF 1.09 MB)
Patuharakeke Te Iwi Trust Board
Juliane Chetham – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021) (PDF 10.3 MB)
Ngātiwai Trust Board
Aperahama Edwards – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021) (PDF 4.99 MB)
Keir Volkering – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021) (PDF 4.65 MB)
Keir Volkering – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 744 KB)
Te Ohu Kaimoana
Lisa Te Heuheu – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021) (PDF 9.19 MB)
Lisa Te Heuheu – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 725 KB)
Whaimutu Dewes – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021) (PDF 3.95 MB)
Sir Tipene O’Regan – Evidence in chief (21 May 2021) (PDF 817 KB)
Te Rūnanga Ā Iwi Ō Ngāpuhi
Hugh Rihari – Evidence in chief (17 May 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 6.74 MB)
Hugh Rihari – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 777 KB)
Wane Wharerau – Evidence in chief (17 May 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 4.7 MB)
Paul Knight – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 1.31 MB)
Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Rēhia
Nora Rameka – Evidence in chief (25 May 2021) (PDF 830 KB)
Kipa Munro – Evidence in chief (25 May 2021) [page 1 – Appendix 3] (PDF 23.84 MB)
Kipa Munro – Evidence in chief (25 May 2021) [Appendix 4 onwards] (PDF 23.84 MB)
Kipa Munro – Rebuttal (25 June 2021) (PDF 770 KB)

Ecology and Natural Character

Evidence from Simon West includes redaction in line with a court confidentiality order (PDF 457 KB) included in the 11 May decision. 

Joint witness statements
Joint Witness Statement – Ecology (10 June 2021) (PDF 2.71 MB)
Bay of Islands Maritime Park Incorporated and Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated
Dr Nicholas Shears – Evidence in chief (19 March 2021) (PDF 1.71 MB)
Dr Nicholas Shears – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 712 KB)
Dr Mark Morrison – Evidence in chief (19 March 2021) (PDF 1.22 MB)
Dr Rebecca Stirnemann – Evidence in chief (19 March 2021) (PDF 4.54 MB)
Dr Rebecca Stirnemann – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 807 KB)
Dr Victoria Froude – Evidence in chief (19 March 2021) (PDF 6.04 MB)
Dr Victoria Froude – Supplementary brief (19 April 2021) (PDF 1.43 MB)
Dr Victoria Froude – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 872 KB)
Te Uri o Hikihiki
Vincent Kerr – Evidence in chief (25 March 2021) (PDF 19.92 MB)
Vincent Kerr – Supplementary brief (14 May 2021) (PDF 1.49 MB)
Vincent Kerr – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 768 KB)
Di Lucas – Evidence in chief (7 April 2021) (PDF 21.12 MB)
Dr Simon Thrush – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 809 KB)
Northland Regional Council
Dr Philip Ross – Evidence in chief (16 April 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 2.09 MB)
Dr Philip Ross – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 991 KB)
Minister for Oceans and Fisheries and Minister of Conservation
Enrique Pardo – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 6.09 MB)
Enrique Pardo – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 687 KB)
Fishing Industry Parties
Simon West – Evidence in chief_Redacted (21 May 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 23.11 MB)
Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Rēhia
Agreed Statement of Facts – Ecology (24 June 2021) (PDF 893 KB)

Economics

Bay of Islands Maritime Park Incorporated and Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated
Timothy Denne – Evidence in chief (19 March 2021) (PDF 824 KB)
Timothy Denne – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 709 KB)

Fisheries

Some of the fisheries evidence is redacted (not published), in line with a court confidentiality order (PDF 457 KB) included in the 11 May decision. 

Joint witness statements
Joint Witness Statement – Fisheries Issues (11 June 2021) (PDF 788 KB)
Minister for Oceans and Fisheries and Minister of Conservation
Alicia McKinnon – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 3.24 MB)
Jacob Hore – Evidence in chief (Fisheries Activities – Addressing amended relief as to area - 22 June 2021_Redacted) (PDF 4.57 MB)
Jacob Hore – Evidence in chief (Fisheries Management) (14 May 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 2.41 MB)
Fishing Industry Parties
Graeme Bailey – Evidence in chief_Redacted (16 May 2021) (PDF 729 KB)
Mark Ngata – Evidence in chief_Redacted (17 May 2021) (PDF 992 KB)
Mark Semmens – Evidence in chief_Redacted (16 May 2021) (PDF 711 KB)
Thomas Clark – Evidence in chief_Redacted (14 May 202; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 1.29 MB)
New Zealand Sports Fishing Council
Andrew Johnson – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021) (PDF 709 KB)
Jonathan Holdsworth – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021) (PDF 1.41 MB)
Jonathan Holdsworth – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 698 KB)
Barry Torkington – Evidence in chief (17 May 2021) (PDF 808 KB)
Ngātiwai Trust Board
Keir Volkering – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021) (PDF 4.65 MB)
Keir Volkering – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 744 KB)
Te Ohu Kaimoana
Lisa Te Heuheu – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021) (PDF 9.19 MB)
Lisa Te Heuheu – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 725 KB)
Whaimutu Dewes – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021) (PDF 3.95 MB)
Sir Tipene O’Regan – Evidence in chief (21 May 2021) (PDF 817 KB)
Kim Drummond – Evidence in chief (17 May 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 2.32 MB)
Kim Drummond – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 1.09 MB)
Te Rūnanga Ā Iwi Ō Ngāpuhi
Hugh Rihari – Evidence in chief (17 May 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 6.74 MB)
Hugh Rihari – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 777 KB)
Wane Wharerau – Evidence in chief (17 May 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 4.7 MB)
Paul Knight – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 1.31 MB)
Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Rēhia
Agreed Statement of Facts – Fisheries Issues_Redacted (22 June 2021) (PDF 4.21 MB)

Planning

Joint witness statements
Joint Witness Statement – Planning (21 June 2021) (PDF 3.48 MB)
Bay of Islands Maritime Park Incorporated and Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated
Peter Reaburn – Evidence in chief (20 March 2021) (PDF 9.26 MB)
Peter Reaburn – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 996 KB)
Te Uri o Hikihiki
Dr Mark Bellingham – Evidence in chief (7 April 2021) (PDF 1.16 MB)
Dr Mark Bellingham – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 829 KB)
Northland Regional Council
James Griffin – Evidence in chief (16 April 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 890 KB)
James Griffin – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 747 KB)
Minister for Oceans and Fisheries and Minister of Conservation
Murray Brass – Evidence in chief (14 May 2021) (PDF 1005 KB)
Fishing Industry Parties
Dr Philip Mitchell – Evidence in chief (21 May 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 1.18 MB)
Te Ohu Kaimoana
Dr Philip Mitchell – Evidence in chief (21 May 2021; updated 22 June 2021) (PDF 1.18 MB)
Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Rēhia
Agreed Statement of Facts – Planning (21 June 2021) (PDF 2.83 MB)

Recreation and tourism

Bay of Islands Maritime Park Incorporated and Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated
Jeroen Jongejans – Evidence in chief (19 March 2021) (PDF 1.34 MB)
Julia Riddle – Evidence in chief (19 March 2021) (PDF 1.03 MB)
Craig Johnston – Evidence in chief (19 March 2021) (PDF 1.03 MB)
Craig Johnston – Rebuttal (22 June 2021) (PDF 705 KB)